Portadown Orangeman takes first step in potential legal action against Michelle O’Neill over Drumcree dispute
A Portadown Orangeman has taken the first step in potential legal action against First Minister Michelle O’Neill for allegedly breaching her pledge of office during the Drumcree marching dispute.
Alan Hynes may seek to judicially review the Sinn Fein Vice President over her participation in protests to block the flashpoint route along the town’s Garvaghy Road.
He also claims statements she later made in the Stormont Assembly were in conflict with the Ministerial Code to uphold the rule of law.
Preliminary correspondence sent today as part of a possible challenge contends Mr Hynes was unlawfully prevented from exercising his rights to take part in the parade.


“Personal disagreement with the law cannot justify conduct contrary to the obligations (Mrs O’Neill) has undertaken in the pledge of office,” the pre-action protocol letter alleged.
Mr Hynes is a member of the Portadown Lodge at the centre of a stand-off which developed over the Orange Order’s bid to march on the mainly nationalist Garvaghy Road for the first time since 1998.
They originally planned to return from Drumcree Church via the disputed route on September 27 this year.
But despite a High Court ruling that the Parades Commission’s decision to approve the contentious procession was lawful, Mrs O’Neill and other political representatives were among hundreds of people who blocked the road.
Secretary of State Sir Chris Bryant subsequently intervened to ban the march on October 9 due to concerns about the potential for serious public disorder.
By that stage police had launched an investigation into the protests on the Garvaghy Road.
The First Minister also rejected calls from unionists to resign over her role in the road block, describing the planned march as “morally wrong”.
Questioned about court rulings on the parade dispute during an Assembly session on October 5 she reportedly stated: “When the law is wrong I will stand firmly against it.”
Mr Hynes’ solicitors have now sent correspondence to the First Minister’s legal representatives claiming she has violated an obligation to comply with the Ministerial Code.
Her alleged participation in and encouragement of the roadblock, along with subsequent statements, were in breach of a statutory duty contained in the Northern Ireland Act 1998 to act in accordance with the pledge of office, papers contend.
According to Mr Hynes’ legal team, the unlawful obstruction prevented him from exercising his rights to freedom of religion, expression and peaceful assembly protected under European law.
The letter includes a request for the alleged breaches to be acknowledged by November 24.
It added: “An expedited response is requested because of the alleged continuing damage to public confidence in the rule of law and the Applicant’s concern, arising from the First Minister’s statements, that similar conduct may recur.”