Decision on Ballymena HMO refusal is overturned

A decision by Mid and East Antrim Borough Council to refuse change of use from dwelling to house of multiple occupation at 119 Broughshane Street, Ballymena, has been overturned by the Planning Appeals Commission.

Full planning permission has been granted to applicant Joe McLaughlin following a decision by Commissioner Hannah Ellison.

General view of Broughshane Street, Ballymena. Picture: Googleplaceholder image
General view of Broughshane Street, Ballymena. Picture: Google

The Commissioner’s report said: “The main issue is whether there is adequate parking provision for the proposed development.

"There are no specific policies in the Ballymena Area Plan which are pertinent to the appeal proposal.

"This appeal concerns a three-storey end-of-terrace property located on the eastern side of Broughshane Street. It is of traditional proportions and appearance and has a two-storey rear outrigger and a small rear yard. The property is currently in use as a six- bedroom dwelling.”

It was noted that the adjacent two properties in the “short terrace” each have permission to be converted into apartments.

"The appeal proposal seeks permission for the conversion of the host property to a six bedroom house of multiple occupation (HMO) and a second floor extension to the rear.,” the report said.

"The council did not raise any concerns with the proposed extension. However, it is concerned that there is inadequate parking provision to accommodate the appeal proposal and that this would, in turn, impact upon servicing.

"At the hearing, the council confirmed its concerns with respect of ‘servicing’ were not in the sense of deliveries, refuse collections and general operations associated with the development. Rather, its concerns relate to the vehicle manoeuvres which would arise from future occupiers trying to find a parking space near to where they live.

"However, not only did the council confirm it had no evidence to support its concerns that vehicle movements associated with the proposal would disrupt traffic flow, but it also stated that it does not have concerns with the proposal in respect of its effect on the character of the area.

"I consider the council’s reference to servicing and its reliance on policy are somewhat misplaced.

"I will nevertheless have regard to vehicle movements and any subsequent effect on matters such as the flow of traffic and congestion in the round when considering the parking demand of the proposal and parking availability in the locality.”

The report noted that the local authority, having regard to the 2005 Parking Standards, considers that the parking provision for the existing property would be three spaces and the provision required for the appeal development would also be three spaces.

"Whilst the council accept that the existing and proposed provision is the same, it suggests that as the proposed development fails to provide the required, designated spaces, it therefore fails to meet the required standard,” it said.

The Commissioner continued: “Although I accept that the appeal development does not include off-street parking provision, there would be no change in the parking demand when compared to the existing use.”

She indicated that a parking survey was carried out by the appellant.

"I consider that it serves to demonstrate that there is sufficient capacity within walking distance of the appeal site to accommodate the demand of the appeal proposal, both on-street and within the nearby carpark, in the evening and overnight,” the Commissioner explained.

placeholder image
Read More
Fab photos of Christmas lights being switched on in Ballymena and Broughshane be...

"Although demand for on-street parking spaces is typically higher in the evenings and overnight, this is more often the case in predominantly residential areas. The appeal site falls within a town centre location thus the parking demand is likely to be different.

"I consider that the three spaces required for the appeal proposal could be accommodated by the existing capacity in the locality, as it is currently.

"I consider that the vehicle movements associated with the appeal proposal would assimilate into this town centre location and that no issue arises in respect of comings and goings which would be generated.

"The council has raised no objections to the proposal’s effect on matters including housing provision in the area, waste, residential amenity, crime and anti-social behaviour, the living conditions which would be provided for future occupiers or whether the proposal would set a precedent. Having regard to all of the evidence before me, there is no reason for me to find otherwise.

"There is adequate parking provision for the proposed development at full standard or the reduced level. The council has failed to sustain its reason for refusal, thus the appeal shall succeed.”

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice