Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council’s £32m underspend ‘fails’ ratepayers
A revealed NI council’s £32m underspend has raised cash transparency concerns over residents being “hit in the pocket” with rates rises in a cost of living crisis.
Tens of millions of pounds were not spent across various Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council departments since the new local authority formed in 2015.
The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) through a council source, has seen the total figure, which includes a breakdown of underspend with payroll the highest at almost £8.5m to the end of the 2016 financial year.
The LDRS contacted all political parties and independents at the council for comment.


Lisburn North independent councillor Gary Hynds said: “Perhaps those councillors who criticised me for opposing higher rates should now be apologising not to me, but to the ratepayers they have failed to properly represent.
“My job as a councillor is to protect the ratepayer, not rubber-stamp higher rates while millions go unspent.
“Too many councillors have failed to properly scrutinise budgets, challenge spending and demand genuine value for money.”
A further breakdown of figures shows Leisure Services has the second highest underspend at over £7.6m.
A spokesperson for the UUP said: “Every year, any council underspend is either carried in full into the next year’s budget or ringfenced for specific projects.
“Either way, the money is accounted for when the next year’s rate is set. It reduces what has to be raised from ratepayers, or it pays for investment that would otherwise come from future rates.
“Rate-setting is open and thorough. Councillors from every party work closely with the council’s finance officers each year, every underspend is set out in full, and in most years the rate has had cross-party support.
“That’s part of the reason Lisburn and Castlereagh has kept the lowest domestic district rate in Northern Ireland, which matters a great deal to families during a cost-of-living crisis.”
The accounts have also shown some lack of transparency over an unidentified ‘Other’ underspend ranking close to the top at £7.35m.
The impact of Covid has also had an effect proving the most underspend in one year at a total of just over £7m.
An Alliance Party spokesperson said: “We are very mindful of the pressures facing households and businesses during the ongoing cost of living crisis.
“We always strive to strike the lowest possible district rate while continuing to protect and deliver essential council services and projects which serve to benefit everyone right across Lisburn and Castlereagh.
“Throughout the rates setting process, Alliance will continue to scrutinise council finances to ensure every pound is spent wisely and in the best interests of local residents and businesses.
“We also continue to challenge proposals for additional in-year expenditure that has not already been accounted for through the rates-setting process, recognising that any new spending must be carefully justified and deliver clear value for ratepayers.”
Lisburn North SDLP councillor Pat Catney said: “People across Lisburn and Castlereagh will rightly question how the council has recorded over £32 million in underspends while continuing to increase rates.
“Families and small businesses are already under huge financial pressure, and every penny matters.
“The SDLP voted against these rates increases because we believed more should have been done to protect local people.
“It is hard to justify asking households to dig deeper into their pockets when figures like these are emerging.
“Ratepayers deserve a clear explanation of how these underspends arose and whether more could have been done to keep rates down.
“People work hard for their money, and the council has a duty to make sure they are getting a fair deal.”
A DUP spokesperson said: “DUP councillors are committed to keeping rates as low as possible and ensuring ratepayers get value for money.
“Under a DUP chairperson, the council agreed a zero rate rise during the pandemic to ease pressure on households.
“We will continue to scrutinise spending, press for fair rates and work to ensure Lisburn and Castlereagh retains the lowest domestic rate of any council in Northern Ireland.
“We also want the best possible facilities and outcomes for ratepayers, while protecting essential services and keeping the council on a sound financial footing.”
Castlereagh South Sinn Fein councillor Ryan Carlin said: “Sinn Féin will continue to press council to ensure that public money is spent wisely, that every penny delivers for local people, and that any savings made are passed back to ratepayers.
“We believe in fair rates, first-class public services and value for money.
“Ratepayers deserve nothing less, and we will continue to hold Council to account to ensure they get the benefits.”
The council regularly boasts on its website “to continue to have the lowest domestic district rate in Northern Ireland” with an increase of 4.25% this year.
A council spokesperson said: “Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council’s financial performance is published annually through its audited accounts and prior year outturns (underspends) are taken into account when setting future budgets.
“Ratepayer costs are always an important consideration as part of the rate-setting process.
“Through prudent financial management, the council has been able to invest in significant projects and initiatives that benefit residents, communities and businesses across the council area.
“This includes delivering the new Dundonald International Ice Bowl without the need for external borrowing, avoiding substantial additional financing costs for ratepayers.
“The council has also supported community and sporting facilities through investment in projects such as Ballymacash Sports Academy, Lisburn Rugby Club and Canal Boxing Club.
“In addition, the Future City Fund continues to support new and expanding businesses in our city centre, including Square Bistro and the Haslem Hotel.
“Financial resources are continually reviewed and directed towards agreed priorities that support services, infrastructure, economic growth and community development across Lisburn and Castlereagh.”
